A heat pump can cost less to run than propane during some or many heating hours, but there is no single Ontario-wide answer. Your delivered propane price, added electricity cost and the heat pump’s performance determine the cost of heat. Annual results also depend on how much heating shifts and which propane charges remain.
Compare equal amounts of useful heat first. Then include backup operation, equipment costs and continuing charges. A lower fuel cost alone does not prove a payback period or establish that propane can be removed.
Start with delivery records, not “tanks per month”
Gather a full year’s invoices showing dates, litres, unit prices, taxes and separate fees. Record whether propane also serves water heating, cooking, a fireplace or a generator. Those uses need their own treatment.
A delivery total is not automatically consumption: the amount left in the tank at the start and end may differ. Ask your supplier which records are available, and label estimates clearly. An equal-payment amount describes billing, not measured monthly heating demand.
Use your home’s delivered price. A vehicle-filling-station price or someone else’s contract does not establish what your household pays.
Put both options on the same heat basis
Useful heat means the heat supplied after the assumed heating-system losses. The simplified comparison is:
Propane cost per useful kWh = delivered dollars per litre ÷ (kWh of fuel energy per litre × heating efficiency).
Heat-pump cost per useful kWh = added electricity dollars per kWh ÷ applicable coefficient of performance (COP).
Natural Resources Canada explains COP as heat output relative to electrical input. Performance at one test condition is different from a seasonal or whole-system estimate. Ask what the figure includes and which conditions it represents.
For the arithmetic below, NRCan’s fuel-energy table supplies 25.3 MJ per litre of propane and 3.6 MJ per electrical kWh. That is about 7.028 kWh of fuel energy per litre. We use only the physical conversion from that older guide, not its historical prices or appliance advice. An actual estimate needs compatible fuel-energy and efficiency assumptions.
A worked example you can challenge
Hypothetical teaching inputs, October 27, 2026—not current rates, a quote, a real 519 job or a performance forecast: propane $1.00/L; heating efficiency 95%; added electricity $0.20/kWh; effective COP 2.5 for the heat being compared.
| Calculation | Result |
|---|---|
| Propane: $1 ÷ ((25.3 ÷ 3.6) × 0.95) | 14.98¢ per useful kWh |
| Heat pump: $0.20 ÷ 2.5 | 8.00¢ per useful kWh |
| Difference × 10,000 useful kWh displaced | About $698 |
The displaced heat corresponds to approximately 1,498 litres at the assumed efficiency. The $698 is a simplified fuel-cost difference for that portion of heat. It is not net annual household savings. Equipment purchase, financing, ownership differences and any costs that continue still need accounting.
If the heat pump supplies less heat than assumed, multiply by that smaller displaced amount. Do not apply the difference to propane that still heats water or runs another appliance.
See when the result reverses
All inputs in this sensitivity table are hypothetical. Values are cents per useful kWh; the propane rows retain 95% efficiency.
| Input | Useful-heat cost |
|---|---|
| Propane $0.70/L | 10.48¢ |
| Propane $1.00/L | 14.98¢ |
| Propane $1.30/L | 19.47¢ |
| Electricity $0.20/kWh; COP 1.5 | 13.33¢ |
| Electricity $0.20/kWh; COP 2.5 | 8.00¢ |
| Electricity $0.30/kWh; COP 1.5 | 20.00¢ |
| Electricity $0.30/kWh; COP 2.5 | 12.00¢ |
Against the $1.00/L propane example, 20¢ electricity at COP 1.5 costs less per unit of heat; 30¢ electricity at that same COP costs more. A favourable rate and favourable COP cannot describe every winter hour.
Dividing electricity price by propane’s useful-heat cost gives a rough cost-crossover COP. With the base inputs it is about 1.34. This is arithmetic, not a thermostat setting or a switchover temperature. Equipment limits, capacity and control design need professional assessment.
Which costs actually change?
The Ontario Energy Board’s bill explanation distinguishes fixed and usage-related electricity charges. Estimate the increase caused by heating, including applicable variable charges. Do not charge the heat pump an existing fixed fee that would be paid anyway, or omit usage-related costs because they appear outside the electricity line.
| Situation | Include in the comparison | Important exception |
|---|---|---|
| Propane stays as backup | Remaining fuel, tank and service terms | Running less does not prove rental or minimum-use charges disappear. |
| Other appliances still use propane | Their consumption and continuing supply arrangement | Space-heating conversion is not a whole-property fuel exit. |
| Considering full propane removal | All appliance changes and supplier exit terms | Ask for written tank-removal, rental and contract details. |
| AC already needs replacement | Complete AC option versus complete heat-pump option | A working AC and a failed AC create different purchase baselines. |
Published utility comparisons can demonstrate a method without matching your house. For example, Manitoba Hydro’s comparison explicitly includes regional rates, seasonal assumptions and tank rental. Its Manitoba cost totals should not be treated as Ontario estimates.
A bill-and-quote worksheet
- Fuel: list delivered litres, price dates, taxes and separate fees; reconcile tank inventory and non-heating uses.
- Electricity: record your utility, rate plan and estimated added bill cost across relevant hours or tiers.
- Heating: request the estimated useful heating demand and the share assigned to each heat source.
- Performance: identify the model combination, relevant operating conditions and treatment of defrost, auxiliaries and backup.
- Continuing costs: mark each fee as removed, reduced, unchanged or unknown, with its evidence.
- Purchase: compare complete installed alternatives, then show favourable and unfavourable operating scenarios.
If a scenario has no positive net yearly saving, a savings-based payback is not established for that scenario. Cooling needs and comfort goals can still matter; describe them separately from financial returns.
Common questions
Can I keep propane backup?
That is a system-design question. Ask a qualified contractor to assess the house, equipment combination and controls. Do not assume a particular furnace is compatible or change its operating settings from a cost calculation.
Is one quoted COP enough?
No single favourable operating point establishes annual consumption. Ask for the conditions, heating share and included electrical loads behind the estimate.
Should a rebate decide the comparison?
Use an incentive only after the actual project’s current eligibility and application requirements are confirmed. Show a no-incentive case as well; an advertised maximum is not secured funding.
For the broader equipment choice, read AC vs heat pump and our HVAC quote comparison guide.
Bring the bills to the conversation
Tell 519 Furnace what heats your home, what needs replacing and what you intend to keep. Bring delivery invoices and equipment details so the next conversation starts with the actual project.

